Most people have noticed by now that the new “Blogger” service, recently acquired by Google, has changed their commenting format. Before, a user could put her/his name and linkback to her/his blog into the comments field and in doing so, link their blog in the comment chain. This is and has been the lifeblood of blog networking since it’s inception in the late 90’s. A few people responded to me recently, defending Blogger, that all they did was do away with anonymous commenting … not true. Though it may seem that is what they did, anonymous commenting is still allowed. The catch is, Google will know who you are because you must have a Google/Blogger blog. This is bad for many reasons but here are a few for starters:
What they want to do now is sign up for a Google account which allows you to add your user name to the comment, add a nickname or leave an anonymous comment. But even if you have a Google account it does not allow you to link to your blog url unless you are on Blogger. So, as you can see, it still allows anonymous commenting. Doing away with such commenting is not their true motive.
So what is it then? I am not sure. Here are a few guesses:
- Get more blogs hosted on Blogger, regardless of its many limitations.
- Eliminate all blog-hop traffic to non-Blogger blogs. (this is now in place)
- Eliminate all “back-links” within 6 months from Blogger blogs to non-Blogger blogs that once increased their page rank and Technorati rankings.
- Harm advertising rankings that enable many bloggers to make profit.
- Make Blogger a network to find only new Blogger blogs and prevent discovery of the millions of blogs self-hosted or hosted outside of Blogger, such as mine.
So, whereas before I simply found the comment system cumbersome on Blogger, I now find it meddlesome and non-inclusive of the breadth of bloggers that exist in 2008.
Bad move Blogger. Let them know by digging, stumbling, and otherwise sharing this and any post related to the “new Blogger.” Maybe we can get them to see the errors of this approach to commenting.
Gracias.
Related posts